2ND STUDY TO
EXPAND UPON THIS PHENOMENON
DATELINE-WEST LAFAYETTE,
INDIANA, ISSUED TO MEDIA ON DECEMBER 16 1996
Purdue University researchers
found in a June, 1996 study that boys with low blood levels of
essential omega-3 fatty acids, have a greater tendency to have
problems with behavior, learning, and health consistent with attention
deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). In response to this breakthrough,
a second Purdue University study has been launched to expand upon
the hypothesis (1) that oral supplementation of specific fatty
acids will increase the concentrations of long chain n-6 and n-3
fatty acids in the blood and (2) that increased blood fatty acid
levels will improve behavior of ADHD children.
"There are two
types of fatty acids that musts be obtained from the foods-- such
as fish, seafood and polyunsaturated oils-- we eat because the
body cannot synthesize them," commented John R. Burgess,
assistant professor of food and nutrition at Purdue University,
who led the first study and is heading up the follow-up research
as well. He added, "Omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids are both
essential to the body. However evidence is accumulating that a
deficiency of omega-3 fatty acids may be tied to behavior problems,
learning, and health problems."
THIRST FOR
KNOWLEDGE
Previous studies have
focused on essential fatty acid metabolism in children with ADHD.
These children were found to exhibit greater thirst and symptoms
of eczema, asthma, and other allergies which are associated with
essential fatty acid deficiency. (11)
ADHD Profile
ADHD is the most common
behavioral disorder in children, affecting between 3% and 5% of
school age youngsters (6). ADHD is diagnosed more often in boys
than girls. The diagnosis is used to describe children who are
inattentive, impulsive, hyperactive. ADHD children have problems
paying attention, listening to instructions, completing tasks,
fidgeting and squirming, hyperactivity, blurting out answers and
interrupting others. These behaviors often severely affect school
performance, family relationships, and social interaction with
peers. Approximately 20-25% of children with ADHD show one or
more specific learning disabilities in math, reading, and spelling.
(5)
DRUGS &
OTHER STRATEGIES
The cause is unknown
and thought to be biological and multifactorial. Psycho-stimulant
drugs, such as Ritalin, Cylen and Dexedrine are often used to
calm children with ADHD at about 75% effectiveness rate (8). The
advantages of using these medications include rapid response,
ease of use, effectiveness, and relative safety. Disadvantages
include possible side effects, such as decreased appetite and
growth, insomnia, increased irritability, and rebound hyperactivity
when the drug wears off (9). These medications do not address
the underlying cause(s) of ADHD. Thus, this study to elucidate
the potential contributors to the behaviors problems in ADHD may
lead to more effective treatment strategies for some children.
METHODOLOGY
Ninety children with
symptoms of essential fatty acid deficiencies have been recruited
for this study. Children were chosen on the basis of parents and
teachers completing the Disruptive Behavior Disorders (DAD) Rating
Scales (27), a health questionnaire, and a three day diet record.
Additionally, a control group of 20 children with no essential
fatty acid deficiency and no behavioral problems were recruited.
Four months was chosen as a sufficient time period of supplementations
to see improvement in fatty acid status based on previous studies
in both animals and humans. (17, 18)
A supplement containing
the specific essential fatty acid derivatives that are depleted
in the 90 children is being used in a double-blind intervention
study with a 3-group parallel (noncrossover) design. The supplement
being used in the study is Efalex Focus, a patented dietary supplement
which combines tuna oil, evening primrose oil, vitamin E and thyme
oil and produced by Efamol Ltd.
The 90 subjects have
been randomly assigned to three groups:
Group A: To receive
a high does of the supplement
Group B: To receive
a low dose of the supplement
Group C: To receive
placebo capsules
The control group of
20 children with no essential fatty acid deficiency and no behavioral
problems were not given any supplementation or placebo, but were
subjected to a similar battery of tests.
The three groups are
balanced with respect to initial behavioral assessment, math achievement,
age, gender, socio-economic an medication status. Blood samples
are being drawn at baseline, two and four months of supplementation
for analysis of fasting plasma and red blood cell fatty acids.
Behavioral and learning changes were assessed before supplementation
using the Teacher 10-Item Conners evaluation and will also be
reviewed during and at the end of the four month intervention.
Drop out rate was anticipated
to be low due to heightened public concern over stimulant drug
use and a desire by parents to explore alternative therapies for
ADHD.
TITLE: Omega-3
Fatty Acids in Boys with Behavior, Learning, and Health Problems
AUTHORS: L.J.
Stevens, S.S. Zentall, M.L. Abate, T. Kuczek, J.R. Burgess
SOURCE:
Physiol Behav 59(4/5) 915-920. 1996
ABSTRACT: The
purpose of the study reported here was to compare behavior, learning
and health problems in boys ages 6-12 with lower plasma phospholipid
total omega-3 or total omega-6 fatty acid levels with those boys
with higher levels of these fatty acids. A greater frequency of
symptoms indicative of essential fatty acid deficiency was reported
by the parents of subjects with lower plasma omega-3 or omega-6
fatty acid concentrations than those with higher levels. A greater
number of behavior problems, accessed by the Conners' Rating Scale,
temper tantrums, and sleep problems were reported in subjects
with lower total omega-3 fatty acid concentrations. Additionally,
more learning and health problems were found in subjects with
lower total omega-3 fatty acid concentrations. (Only more colds
and more antibiotic used were reported by those subjects with
lower total omega-6 fatty acids.) These findings are discussed
in relation to recent findings for omega-3 experimentally deprived
animals.
TITLE:
Essential Fatty Acid Metabolism in Boys with Attention-Deficit
Hyperactivity Disorder.
AUTHORS:
L.J. Stevens, S.S. Zentall, J.L. Deck, M.L. Abate, B.A. Watkins,
S.R. Lipp, J.R. Burgess
SOURCE: American
Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1995 Oct; 62(4): 761-8
ABSTRACT: Attention-deficit
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is the term used to describe children
who are inattentive, impulsive, and hyperactive. The cause is
unknown and is thought to be multifactorial. Based on the work
of others, we hypothesized that some children with ADHD have altered
fatty acid metabolism. The present study found that 53 subjects
with ADHD had significantly lower concentrations of key fatty
acids in the plasma polar lipids (20:4n-6, 20:5n-3, and 22:6n-3)
and in red blood cell total lipids (20:4n-6 and 22:4n-6) than
did the 43 control subjects. Also, a subgroup of 21 subjects with
ADHD exhibiting many symptoms of essential fatty acid (EFA) deficiency
had significantly lower plasma concentrations of 20:4n-6 and 22:6n-3
than did 32 subjects with ADHD with few EFA-deficiency symptoms.
The data are discussed with respect to cause, but the precise
reason for lower fatty acid concentrations in some children with
ADHD is not clear.
TITLE:
Benefit of docosahexaenoic acid supplements to dark adaptation
in dyslexics
AUTHORS: B.
Jacqueline Stordy
SOURCE:
Lancet 5th August 1995, 346:8971
ABSTRACT:
Sir-Makrides and colleagues (June 10, p 1463) provide strong evidence
that docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) is an essential nutrient for the
optimum neural maturation of term infants as assessed by visual
evoked potential acuity. I have data indicating that DHA supplementation
in adult dyslexics improves dark adaptation (scotopic vision)
and thus DHA may also be a dietary essential for this condition.
We measure dark adaptation
with a Friedmann Visual Field Analyser 2, set for the dark adaptation
function, in ten adults with dyslexia and ten controls. Dyslexics
showed poorer dark adaptation than controls, especially in the
second part of the curve, which corresponds with rod dark adaptation
(figure a: repeated measures Anova p,0.05). We subsequently tested
the possibility that dark adaptation might be influenced by DHA.
For 1 month five dyslexics and five controls were given 480 mg
of DHA daily with no additional vitamin A or vitamin D. Dark adaptation
was then retested (figure, b and c). In four controls DHA had
no effect on dark adaptation, although in one (a strict vegetarian)
adaptation clearly improved. By contrast, in the dyslexics with
poor scotopic vision DHA consistently and significantly improved
dark adaptation (figure, b: paired t-rest on final rod threshold,
p<0.04).
It has been recognized
that dyslexics have both retinal and central processing defects,*
but defective dark adaptation has to my knowledge not previously
been reported. DHA is a key fatty avid in both retina and brain
and is usually present in large quantities in these tissues. In
these studies I show the benefit of DHA supplementations for one
aspect of retinal function. I have found that DHA supplements
given to dyslexics can also be associated with improvement is
reading ability and behavior. These reports are anecdotal and
subjective but more formal controlled studies are in preparation.
* Grosser GS, Spafford
CS. Light Sensitivity in Peripheral Retinal Fields of Dyslexic
and Proficient Readers. Perceptual Motor Skills 1990; 71:467-77.
Galaburda A. Livingstone
M. Evidence for a Magnocellular Defect in Developmental Dyslexia.Ann
NY Acad Aci 1993: 71-81